Lyon: CAP reform debate must shift focus

1.19.00pm GMT Mon 1st Mar 2010

George Lyon, Liberal Democrat MEP for Scotland, has voiced his concern that the debate on reform of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) is in danger of descending into divisiveness.

On Saturday, Mr Lyon attended a special meeting of Argyll and Islands NFU to discuss the future of the CAP.

Commenting, Mr Lyon said:

"Disappointingly, the debate on CAP reform has so far focused on who the support should go to. There has been much talk of winners and losers in the reform process.

"This kind of talk will get us nowhere. The debate needs to shift to the big battle of defending the CAP budget from deep and painful cuts.

"The industry needs powerful arguments to prove why CAP should continue to be funded at current levels.

"Food security will be one key defence but it is not enough on its own. By emphasising the role that farmers play in delivering public goods such as preservation of the environment and maintaining high standards of animal welfare and food quality we can make the case for CAP funding security.

"In addition, we must spell out loud and clear the role agriculture can play in tackling climate change through increased efficiency to reduce carbon emissions and increased carbon sequestration.

"It is vital we develop these wider arguments to persuade consumers and taxpayers that the CAP is still relevant and provides good value for money."

John Semple, Vice-Chairman of NFU Scotland's Argyll and Islands Region said:

"In a vulnerable region like Argyll and the islands, the justification for continued public support of the agricultural industry is easy to make. Not only does such support underpin the economic activities of farming and food production, but it is crucial in continuing to deliver the social and environmental benefits that we deliver as farmers managing the land.

"The way in which support is delivered to the industry is set to change and reform of the Common Agricultural Policy to be implemented in 2013 and beyond has significant implications for this region. The debate on the future shape of the CAP is happening now. George's experience as a former farmer and politician for the area is hugely beneficial and, as a member of the influential Agriculture committee in Brussels, he has an insight in how any decisions taken are likely to impact on a region like ours."